In all our sanctuaries we sit at risk
  • Where is the Church ? I don’t see it anywhere.

    The Anglican Church is having trouble deciding whether to introduce women bishops. Within the Church, there have been agitation, discussion and arguments over the move for ages. It is possible that, outside the Church, very few people would have any interest whatsoever, in either the arguments or in the development.

    By which I do not mean that the issue, and the principles behind it, are not important. I mean that it is simply bewildering and deeply depressing that an organisation whose over-riding purpose is to support and give shelter to the best that humankind can be, should have needed to debate this issue for one moment, let alone for years. Of course there should be women bishops. How can you have time or energy to spare for troubling over this issue ? We who are not of the Church can only look on aghast at the inward-facing anachronistic irrelevance of it all, this diversion and waste of good energy, to the point of dereliction and irresponsibility.

    And of course one thinks in the same breath of the same Church’s agonisings over homosexuality. Oh dear oh dear, at all costs we must keep our precious Church together, even if it means doing sorry deals with bigots and fundamentalists, these Pharisees still hissing at the foot of the cross, thereby making nonsense of what the Church means and stands for. In supporting another move entirely, the Rt Reverend Christopher Hill has recently declared that  “of vital importance to the body of Christ [is] our care and concern for the equality of all human beings as created by God and redeemed in Christ”. Well, quite.

    I have to ask myself why do I feel such despair that the Church is allowing itself to be pre-occupied, defeated and reduced by internal issues of this kind – over which a present Christ, Love in person, would not have a moment’s doubt – while remaining largely silent and on the side-lines over issues that are central, universal, and presently even desperate. Here is the dereliction I referred to earlier. We are indeed looking at the abyss.

    Above all, I am thinking of our Society’s enslavement to material gain and individual acquisition as be-all, end-all and measure of individual worth, and our tolerance of the consequent vast inequalities within the population, as some individuals demand and are able to fetch, largely with impunity, incomes on a scale that is obscene, anti-social, and simply void of reason or measure. The present scandal over the bankers is merely the latest in a series of scandals involving various walks of modern life ; clearly they describe a whole Society, not just particular guilty tribes within it.

    Was not material gain and God’s relationship with Caesar one of the most difficult and central issues and arguments throughout Christ’s ministry ? Give up all you have and follow me, said Love. It is easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than….  In these desperate, shaming and pathological times of wholesale greed and ubiquitous corruption, of lost ways and lost purposes, of sleek dishonest sales talk at all levels, of Western Society reeling and shaking, what is the Church’s position, what witness is it giving, how is it engaged ? Sorry, says the Church, call again later. We’re busy discussing whether gays and women are to be allowed a place in our hierarchies.

    Not so long ago, when Thatcher was publically triumphing over the “defeat” of Communism by the West, the late Cardinal Hume gave a speech which could be interpreted as directly rebuking her. He said that Capitalism and Communism were both systems which had failed fundamentally to befriend humanity and also the environment where we live and have our fragile  being. The Cardinal implied that, far from losing to a success, Communism was merely the first of the two failed systems to collapse.

    In search of guidance, strength and clarity, I find myself turning to a Church born of concepts clearly far too radical for the times in which they were uttered, and seemingly still way in advance of these times in which I find myself alive.

    So where is this Church ? Walking in front of me ? Walking beside me ? I don’t see it anywhere.

    “Nothing is apt to mask the face of God so much as religion.” Martin Buber

    Rogan Wolf
    July 8th 2012

    Posted:


  • Fables and Reflections – The Door which Strangely Opens

    I am uploading with this post the first installment of  “Fables and Reflections,” a collection of short prose pieces which I wrote over a period of around three months in Greece.  Future uploads will consist of just one Fable each. But this first post has two attachments, first the collection’s Introduction and second Fable One. Click on the link words. Exclusive of the Introduction, there will be sixteen fables in all.

    As a series, “Fables and Reflections” varies in approach. Some of the pieces are essentially metaphor, allegory, parable, fable ; others are written more directly as discussion papers. They explore, among other things, the place and meaning of social responsibility and social inclusion, and the  skills required to make  and keep healing human connection,   in a Society otherwise much engaged in transition-fever, aggressive fundamentalism, material acquisiton, denial.

    I believe this collection of pieces is relevant,  especially to people working/struggling along frontiers within Society where the need to connect, and to have skill in doing so, are especially important.

    For various reasons my “publication” strategy will be to put up the fables here one at a time  and later perhaps on the site of a small charity I run called “Hyphen-21”. They’ll go up fortnightly.  At the same time I shall send them out as email attachments to people who have said beforehand they’d be interested. If anyone would prefer to have them sent in hard copy by surface mail, I would be willing to do that too. Just contact me and give me your address.

    The Fables vary in length, but I would say on average that each takes approximately ten minutes to read. If you have them in hard copy, you could read each one over a cup of tea, a half pint, a glass of wine, whatever you fancy.

    Fable 1, “The Door which Strangely Opens,” offers some thoughts on endurance and right action.

    If you think that “Fables and Reflections” has any merit or value, please pass  the collection on, or recommend this site,  to anyone else you think might be interested.

    Best wishes

    Rogan Wolf

    Posted:


  • Was Lazarus such a lucky man ?

    Someone I knew well died this Spring. Her death (from breast cancer) came twenty years after she was first diagnosed. But almost until the end, she refused to accept that death was pending. In her bed at home, she acknowledged the truth only a few hours before she stopped breathing, thereby making honest communication with her loved ones only briefly possible.

    Until those final hours, she had believed that acknowledging the fact that the disease was a mortal one might in itself kill her. She felt that anyone who talked to her about death was introducing negativity into her system,  threatening her life, weakening her hope. Words which acknowledged the disease seemed almost more dangerous to her than the disease itself. She felt that her survival depended on refusing to resign herself and, by extension, that she could actually keep herself alive through the sheer positive power of her denial. She insisted on more time. “I am not a statistic“, she would say. “I shall stand aside.“ Another ten years would do. That round figure in the mind would take from death any power it might have had to lean across her every day and skin cell, causing her heart to plunge to the depths whenever she returned to consciousness in the early mornings, or her fingers to search every few hours through the scarred surfaces of her body, for further signs of the spread of doom.

    That resolution of hers made me think of Lazarus.

    Jesus Christ, maybe under pressure from Mary and Martha, his good friends, brought their brother Lazarus back from the dead.

    The heart lifts. Here’s a happy ending. A pale figure emerges from the tomb to screams of joy. He’s back. Life is cheated of its rules. Loss and pain are pushed back.

    But who is this man who has returned to us ? How can he be the man we knew ?

    Christ has probably fixed things so that the parts of Lazarus that had decomposed are more or less back in place and reasonably hygienic once again. But he can’t fix the fact that Lazarus now knows how it is to die. That is beyond even Christ to change or undo. Lazarus has crossed the frontier that separates the living from the dead. He got through, leaving everyone else behind. We don’t know how it was for him, but he knows, or half-knows. Perhaps he’ll tell us, or half tell us. Perhaps he won’t want to.

    And the story hasn’t ended at all. In a while – and the Gospels don’t tell us when – Lazarus will have to die a second time. By now, Christ himself will be dead and will be sitting alongside His Father, the Creator. So this second time, there will be no return trip. Will Lazarus be sorry ? Or glad ?

    Was he glad that first time, having made the exit which everyone dreads so utterly, to be forced back into the blinding light, for the temporary relief of his sisters, only to have to go through the whole business again, a short while later ?

    Did he dance out of the tomb, wagging his fingers, saying Hi guys, I’m back, let’s
    party ! – now I have a second chance to live awhile, (but also the obligation again to
    die ?)

    We aren’t told how Lazarus lived his second wind and second death – in that new time granted him – how much more joy he experienced, how much more pain, how much human value there was in that meagre period of extra time made possible millennia ago.

    Nor are we told about those crowds who followed Christ around, saying, Save me Lord, Heal me Lord, Bid me Rise up and Walk. We have to assume that He was only able to “rescue”a few of them. How did the majority feel ? Did they blame Him for failing to put things right for them ? Or did they blame themselves ? Or their Carers for failing to push them forward hard enough, or in the right way? What sort of lives did they lead, devoid of that interlude, that stay of execution, which Christ might have delivered to them ? In what spirit did they die ?

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         Rogan Wolf

    Posted:


  • If I Am Already Broken

    sculpture by Dorothy Love at www.dorothylove.co.uk

    Posted:


  • The ground underfoot has a thin crust these days but we’re still talking

    On Saturday  May 7th, I spoke at a conference at Warwick University. It was called “2nd International Symposium on Poetry and Medicine”.

    I gave a short power-point presentation and read a paper.

    Here is the power-point and here is the paper. This version of the latter is slightly longer than the one I actually read.

    I mentioned the fact that the “Poems for…” project I run is out of funds and has been for several months. One or two helpful suggestions were made.

    The funding issue is, incidently, one reason why this blog has gone quiet recently. Another reason is that there is serious illness in my family. I have to give time and self to those things.

    The conference opportunity was exciting. So are other developments just emerging.  I am a bit tight lipped just now, and concentrating fiercely, but am still talking and will talk more here soon.

    Posted:


  • After Rain

    owl_with_helmet

    sculpture by Dorothy Love at www.dorothylove.co.uk

    Posted:


  • The Travails of Gordon Brown

    Here is a poem about the last Emperor of Byzantium. I sent it recently to a married couple I know, who both liked it. She said it’s about me. He said it’s about Gordon Brown.

    The idea behind the poem is that we are all now inheritors of fallen cities, walls of security which have been broken. The fugitive fox has much to teach us.

    We are also perhaps no less apt than ever our ancestors were to go after those who stand or speak out, people we can blame for our woes, confusions and pain. So we are fox-hunters as well, baying with the hounds.


    The Travails of the Last Emperor

    by Rogan Wolf

    2010

    dedicated here to the Right Honourable Gordon Brown, MP, with thanks.


    For centuries, Constantinople, capital of  Byzantium, was the greatest city in the world. Historians maintain that when it fell in the fifteenth century, its last Emperor died on the walls.  But his body was never found and we are free to consider another  possibility : that he simply wandered away  –  on the one side to Thrace,  or on the other, Anatolia …


    Part 1

    The Emperor at Kerbside


    i


    Highness,

    I saw you tonight,

    creeping like a sickly fox

    across our street.


    The camera’s bound

    to have caught you

    in that glare

    of white light


    at the corner –

    would it miss ?

    I didn’t know

    you were still going,


    Highness,

    with your City

    a charnel yard

    of stone


    and bone

    and shard

    of fine crockery.

    There you presided.


    Can death

    be worse than this ?


    ii


    Between our blurred and broken lines

    the fox is worth picking out.

    He guards the word on the tip of all tongues


    the telling we are frantic to avoid.

    He slips between the cars at kerbside

    his home his own slinking


    his homelessness our street.


    iii


    He has moved in !

    I heard him last night

    scuffling by the open window


    emasculating my arrangements there.

    This morning

    as I put the garden


    back together again,

    I knew he was watching me

    from my window !


    iv


    All my life since setting out

    I have carried fragments and relics

    mementoes of a time intact.


    The city is fallen,

    undone and irretrievable.

    Bowed archaeologists scraping about


    shall not ease my desolation.

    The City is fallen.

    I am the ruins.


    v


    He makes grin

    his mask

    and he spins in the air


    his stink

    and lightly

    sleeps


    and lightly

    he shits.

    He has no shame


    in his matter.

    His game

    is defiance of death.


    vi


    There are real advantages

    to being nowhere nowhen

    no profile


    on the radar screen.

    I am the broken emperor

    so when I materialise


    surface breaks

    queues scatter

    and mouths gape in wild surmise.


    vii


    Fox feathery and starved tonight

    emerges from a bank of ivy.

    His back arches, he walks on tip-toe


    and his tail is like the skeleton of a wing.

    The cats take no notice of him.

    They know that they’ll be alive tomorrow.


    viii


    The stillness of the Voice on Sinai

    foxed Moses. He’d made that arduous ascent

    in full expectation of Grandeur and Majesty.


    Still, small and crucified day upon day

    (until at last

    one day of sorrow


    He’ll  simply give up the ghost),

    this was not the God he thought had promised

    to show his people the Way.


    ix


    Cities in the desert

    picked over by camera and crow –


    history grows dim

    the present points to sorrow.

    June 2007

     

     

    Part 2

    The Emperor Unclothed


    i


    Who was that boy

    who said the emperor

    was merely naked ?


    The boy died of course

    almost at once

    his flesh in gobbets


    scattered across the hills.

    Perhaps he was blind.

    For the emperor wore that day


    the sheen of his apartness

    and a shadow so long

    it girded the earth.


    ii


    Have at you, Highness –

    clear of  the multitudes

    free of the robes.


    You’re just quarry now

    shoulders bare and shining ahead –

    fair game.


    We’ll paddle in you,

    your excellency,

    you’ll do us good.


    iii


    A young fox

    most of his fur missing

    pads the ridge of the garden wall.


    He knows he doesn’t belong here

    and to survive the night

    he must glide to perfection


    between each holding

    he must slide with precision

    around each lit space.


    iv


    That wide-eyed small boy

    who proclaimed the obvious to his neighbours

    didn’t live long enough to see the truth –


    that truth is unendurable

    but learning you’ve bowed for years to a lie

    can drive you to murder.


    v


    And the fox said to the boy emperor

    “follow me.


    Let me guide you

    through my web of shadow


    to where the truth lies hidden

    precarious as an embryo.


    Let us sidle

    together.”

    August 2007

     

     

    Part 3

    The Last Emperor in Chaotic Times


    i


    The last emperor stirs.

    Chaos inspires him.


    It brings back memories

    of earlier convulsions


    when he was the apex

    uppermost in disaster.


    Now citadels collapse again

    and strange new progeny stagger


    sleek and bewildered

    across our blasted fields.


    The last emperor hunches

    into a ball, wheezy and crackling


    and hurries to join them.

    He is sure this time


    he will be our chosen one.

    But what is there left to say ?


    It has all been used up.

    All the great redemptive words


    fizzed and burned out

    almost the instant they entered time


    and for millennia

    they’ve hung in countless rooms


    like lumps of raw clay

    twisted and re-modelled


    to ennoble and justify

    the frets and furies that have always been.


    But the last emperor

    has no need of hope.


    He lost it ages back

    amongst the paraphernalia


    of cities and face

    and full diaries.


    This is child’s play.

    Yes indeed, oh yes indeed


    there’s nothing left to say.

    He sings to himself happily.


    Against the odds another chance.

    Against all the odds another chance.


    Let’s try.


    ii


    The last emperor confided

    resting his feet, reaching for the water jug –

    “I had a cheering thought today.


    I realised the past is just

    another set of possibilities

    as rich in guidance and new ideas


    as anything present or still to come.

    The dead may still belong in the dance.”

    The last emperor was almost weeping now.


    “And straightaway, the walls of my City

    renewed themselves in my mind

    and the dead rose from their mass graves


    took back their faces, their noble eyes,

    and became again my counsellors,

    comforting me with their wit and high learning.”


    iii


    When the great City fell all those years ago

    the emperor had to give up communicating

    with crowds. Now he secretes words in code


    under stones and between buses, whisperings

    deep in caves by the shore, scribblings

    borne in small balloons loosed to ride hurricanes.


    It’s more intimate that way, he says,

    more telling

    more effective in getting his message across.


    iv


    He tends to avoid caves for his resting.

    They are too obvious and accessible.

    He goes for between-space

    and between-time

    on the edges of snug living.

    Fly-tips do well, for instance,

    or gaps between fences


    in the more established parts of suburbia

    where arguments over boundaries

    can open things up a bit.

    Allotment huts have proved satisfactory

    shared with the odd fox or down-and-out,

    or patches of spare paving beneath bridges

    beyond where the cyclists pass.


    And like the kestrel and the red kite

    he is drawn to the motorway

    and will often bed down within feet

    of the juggernauts

    blasting through

    their sharp beams searching infinity

    all night.


    v


    Since the last emperor lost his name

    he’s been invisible.


    He asks himself,

    does it matter


    where I place myself

    if no one can find me there ?


    He wanders from city to quiet fastness

    and there’s no difference


    except in the impact on him.

    No one knows he has gone


    and no one takes note of his arrival.

    Yet on the mountain trail


    he adds a small stone

    to each cairn he passes.


    There is no name on it

    and no one will know


    he placed it there.

    But the stones will continue


    to serve and guide

    once the emperor is dead.


    I’ve learned to be

    an invisible servant


    says the last emperor

    to himself.

    October 2008

    Posted:


  • “No language is chauvinistic of itself; it is our misuse of language that makes it so.”

    Now that the new “One World…” poem-poster collection is up at last and as I begin to collect myself again and think about how to make sure that people know it is there, I want to record a good email conversation I had recently with Lakshmi Holmström, translator of the two Tamil poems selected for the new collection. The conversation is reproduced here with Lakshmi’s permission.
    _______________________________________________________________________

    Sent: 31 March 2010 11:17
    From:  Lakshmi Holmström

    Dear Rogan Wolf,

    I am glad the new collection is nearly ready for uploading……I too, of course … would want to support and encourage any initiative which would make Tamil more visible, and the best of Tamil writing more accessible to people who are unaware of this rich literature. But the thrill is in seeing Tamil as part of a spectrum of languages, each making its own wonderful contribution.
    _______________________________________________________________________

    Sent : 31 March 2010 11:50
    From : Rogan Wolf

    …I also think – that there is something almost political about this project, in a healing sense, in that it affirms people in their self-belief and cultural identities, as part of the wider community.

    _______________________________________________________________________

    Sent: 31 March 2010 14:46
    From: Lakshmi Holmström

    Yes … I do agree that there’s a political aspect to your project, which I find truly admirable in that it encourages and celebrates different identities equally, within a world citizenship.

    But I’m also aware that language chauvinism leads to the most bitter nationalism and violence.

    There seems to be a fine line here (between a pride which shares a universality and a pride that turns into narrow chauvinism) which I think one ought to be vigilant about.

    But I do wish you the best…

    _____________________________________________________________________________
    Sent: 16 April 2010 10:06
    From: Rogan Wolf

    I’ve been meaning to reply for a while. I want to thank you for…what you wrote to me in your message of March 31st and yes I know it’s a fine line, but it’s also a vital and precious one, to be worked at and worked on.

    I actually “run” a small charity called “Hyphen-21.” The title is based on the image of human connection itself as a fine line, in fact a hyphen. The source of the image is a book by Martin Buber called I and Thou. The more successfully we nurture the skills of connection between I and Thou, along this fragile line between I and Other, the more chance our communities and our world have of surviving.

    There is a beautful Arabic poem I chose for the first “One World” collection (see “Prison”) The poet Mourid Barghouti wanted to be identified as a Palestinian. I showed it to a friend of mine who is himself a Palestinian. He came to UK as an asylum seeker and now works for the NHS at quite a senior level. My friend read the poem and said it made him come out in goose-pimples – because it spoke to him and for him so vividly as a Palestinian – that he felt he had just discovered the power of speech. There are things at present the Palestinians cannot say, my friend said ; the experience of being Palestinian is not being given real credence or validation at this time, by the outside world. But the poem says it, and far from being prison offered him release. He said that, if he were an NHS patient and saw that poem on a waiting room wall, he would feel respected and recognised by this hosting country, even though it might treat him clumsily and suspiciously in other respects. He was even prepared to suggest that his health might benefit from this poem.

    I lap up that sort of thing, of course. For similar reasons, though to a lesser extent, I do warm a bit to enthusiasm that verges on the nationalistic, which may come from someone whose culture is being reduced and weakened by another in some way, and the psychological and identity issues there must be among a people in that position. In doing that I am not warming to chauvinism, as such, I don’t think, but I might be a bit of a sucker for people who identify themselves as underdogs, and turn to chauvinism as a substitute for true identity. And that’s a real danger.

    The translator of the Barghouti poem mentioned above has something to offer to this discussion. Her name is Radwa Ashour and she is actually the poet’s wife, and an Egyptian academic (they live in Cairo). It was she who suggested the Arabic text should be on the right of the poster. Her suggestion was less because the eyes of the Arabic reader travel right to left, than because, this way, the texts are open and broken to one another, whereas the other way they stand stiff back to stiff back.

    That first bilingual collection of 45 poems is already on the site and can be downloaded. It contains several Arabic poems but no Hebrew. Quite deliberately seeking to balance that, this present new collection will be carrying two Hebrew poems.  But which poets to choose ? Rahel Bluwstein is seen as virtually the national poet for all Israelis ; Amichai was a soldier in his time but was to the left in politics and would not be seen as a Israeli “chauvinist”.

    Similarly, for the new collection I’ve tried hard to identify and select poems in African languages. Should Afrikaans be included ? Yes, so long as it is one of a large enough group of poems by black Africans. Written by someone identified with an earlier oppressive regime ? No. The poet is Ingrid Jonker who was at odds with the Apartheid regime and committted suicide by drowning.

    And again, I have been given permission to adopt and publish Michael Rosen’s commissioned poem celebrating the 60th birthday of the NHS last year. He was asked to write it during the time he was Children’s Poet Laureate. The poem will be in our new collection, alongside translations of it into Punjabi, Turkish, Greek, Somali and – soon afterwards – Arabic and Hebrew. And maybe Tamil and Sinhala ? The idea is obvious – the NHS waiting room is common ground ; people sit there from many cultures and nations, several of them warring or otherwise in conflict ‘back home.’ So let’s choose, for this poem of the waiting room, where people sit together to see the doctor, languages of peoples who elsewhere might be seeking to harm each other’s health.

    Obviously there is a danger of getting a bit omnipotent in all this, delusions of influence, etc. Finally, though, I might record the following slightly paradoxical thought : if it were possible to avoid the charge of seeming to sympathise with oppressive behaviour, by singling out the poetry of nations or regimes guilty of aggressive actions against others, I think it is at least arguable that we should do precisely that – to show them and their neighbours the other side of themselves in their lives, to validate their higher nature and more human identity. It can’t really work in reality, but seems to follow a bit as a line of thought…
    ______________________________________________________________________________
    Sent: 01 June 2010 16:12
    From: Lakshmi Holmström

    Dear Rogan

    I wanted to answer your previous email,  ‘Thoughts on Chauvinism’, but have been very busy with deadlines, besides being away for a  part of  April/May.

    Of course I agree: languages, literatures and above all poetry are among the most powerful ways in which we identify ourselves. Poetry can express for us – as nothing else –  the particularities of a landscape, specifics of memories, sensations to do with a particular way of being.

    But poetry also seems to tap into what is universally felt too. When I do ‘readings’ of my translations of novels [in my language] , there is a lot of ethnographic and cultural detail which I need to gloss for ‘western’ audiences. This isn’t needed at all, in the case of poetry. The particular seems to get subsumed in the universal.

    That first aspect of poetry, I think,  is one reason why a Palestinian or a Tamil (when in exile) reacts so intensely when she/he  sees a poem in her/his language, on the wall of a hospital waiting room in England, or the London Underground….

    But most of us who are transnationals, or who are part of a diaspora, carry multi-identities, too. And poetry, signalling to the universal, the humane, should help us all to heal, to reconcile and build bridges within ourselves and between ourselves.

    You are absolutely right in seeking out poems  in Hebrew or Sinhala which do just that. No language is chauvinistic of itself; it is our misuse of language that makes it so.

    Best wishes

    Lakshmi

    Posted: